Every pillow we score: 78 models ranked

The ranking below holds every pillow with at least 300 buyer ratings. Pillows with smaller pools have a full review and a score too, and they sit in a separate table under the ranking until their pools grow.

When you filter by sleep position, you see the positions each maker names for its pillow. Treat them as the maker's claim: each review then tells you what buyers who sleep that way actually report.

PositionAnySideBackStomach FillAnyShredded memory foamFeather & downDown alternative fiberSolid memory foamTEMPUR memory foamLatexGel grid AdjustableAnyYesNo Price per pillowAnyUnder $30$30 to $60$60 to $100Over $100 BrandAnyBeckham Hotel CollectionUtopia BeddingCoop Sleep GoodsNuzzleTempur-PedicPurpleCasperMyPillowBedsureAmazon BasicsPuredownJOLLYVOGUEQUTOOLSUPA MODERNWEEKENDERPacific CoastSertaEIUEThree Geese

#	Photo	Model	Score	Fill	Adjustable	Stars	Ratings	Per pillow
1		SUPA MODERN Cooling Shredded Memory Foam Pillow	7.9	Shredded memory foam	Yes	4.3	23,026	$19
2		Three Geese Adjustable Layer Goose Feather Pillow	7.9	Feather & down	Yes	4.4	5,006	$44.99
3		QUTOOL Bamboo Rayon Adjustable Pillow	7.8	Shredded memory foam	Yes	4.4	1,546	$19
4		QUTOOL Firm Shredded Memory Foam Pillow	7.8	Shredded memory foam	Yes	4.4	819	$19
5		Coop Sleep Goods Original Adjustable Pillow	7.6	Shredded memory foam	Yes	4.5	64,006	$89
6		QUTOOL Cooling Shredded Memory Foam Pillow	7.5	Shredded memory foam	Yes	4.3	23,187	$20
7		JOLLYVOGUE Down Alternative Pillows, Set of 4	7.5	Down alternative fiber	No	4.5	595	$9.25
8		Serta Medium Soft Bed Pillow	7.4	Down alternative fiber	No	4.4	754	$25
9		Coop Sleep Goods Eden Pillow	7.3	Solid memory foam	Yes	4.4	15,193	$109
10		QUTOOL Double-Sided Cooling Pillow	7.3	Shredded memory foam	Yes	4.3	851	$28
11		Puredown Shredded Memory Foam Pillow	7.3	Shredded memory foam	Yes	4.4	697	$13.50
12		Utopia Bedding Hotel Pillows, Set of 4	7.2	Down alternative fiber	No	4.6	16,598	$7.62
13		JOLLYVOGUE Hotel Collection Pillows, Set of 4	7.2	Down alternative fiber	No	4.4	2,463	$8.25
14		Beckham Hotel Collection Adjustable Memory Foam Pillow	7.2	Shredded memory foam	Yes	4.4	1,728	$45
15		Utopia Bedding Shredded Memory Foam Pillow	7.2	Shredded memory foam	Yes	4.3	327	$20.89
16		JOLLYVOGUE Cooling Firm Pillows	7.1	Down alternative fiber	No	4.4	23,896	$10.50
17		JOLLYVOGUE Firm Supportive Pillows	7.1	Down alternative fiber	No	4.4	9,699	$9.49
18		Nuzzle Adjustable Pillow	7.0	Down alternative fiber	Yes	4.2	10,142	$48.99
19		Bedsure Bed Pillow	6.8	Down alternative fiber	No	4.4	17,327	$16.50
20		SUPA MODERN Thin Stomach Sleeper Pillow	6.8	Solid memory foam	No	4.4	531	$33.99
21		Utopia Bedding Hotel Bed Pillow	6.7	Down alternative fiber	No	4.5	44,116	$12.95
22		Beckham Hotel Collection Bed Pillow	6.6	Down alternative fiber	No	4.3	264,530	$30
23		WEEKENDER Ventilated Gel Memory Foam Pillow	6.6	Solid memory foam	No	4.3	41,758	$29.99
24		Serta Down Illusion Pillow	6.6	Down alternative fiber	No	4.3	1,177	$25.55
25		Puredown White Goose Down Feather Pillow, Made in Japan	6.6	Feather & down	No	4.4	662	$50
26		Utopia Bedding Gusseted Bed Pillow	6.5	Down alternative fiber	No	4.5	80,961	$14.95
27		Puredown Goose Feather & Down Pillow, Cotton Cover	6.5	Feather & down	No	4.2	16,007	$20
28		Amazon Basics Down Alternative Pillow	6.5	Down alternative fiber	No	4.3	12,642	$9.37
29		Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Cloud Pillow	6.5	TEMPUR memory foam	No	4.3	7,646	$71.40
30		WEEKENDER Gel Memory Foam Pillow, Reversible Cover	6.5	Solid memory foam	No	4.4	1,029	$54.57
31		Pacific Coast Firm Goose Feather & Down Pillow	6.5	Feather & down	No	4.2	731	$50
32		Three Geese Goose Feather Pillow, 600 Thread Count	6.3	Feather & down	No	4.3	13,607	$24.99
33		Pacific Coast Goose Feather & Down Hotel Pillow	6.3	Feather & down	No	4.1	2,167	$30
34		Pacific Coast 3-Chamber Feather & Down Pillow	6.3	Feather & down	No	4.1	1,093	$48
35		SUPA MODERN Crescent Side Sleeper Pillow	6.3	Shredded memory foam	Yes	4.2	501	$35.99
36		Pacific Coast Organic Cotton Feather & Down Pillow	6.3	Feather & down	No	4.1	494	$54
37		Puredown Gusseted Goose Feather & Down Pillow	6.2	Feather & down	No	4.2	18,419	$25.95
38		Purple Harmony Pillow	6.2	Latex	No	4.2	7,142	$194
39		Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Cloud Dual Cooling Pillow	6.1	TEMPUR memory foam	No	4.2	4,556	$130.90
40		Casper Essential Pillow	5.9	Down alternative fiber	No	4.4	5,617	$40.50
41		Purple Pillow, GelFlex Grid	5.9	Gel grid	Yes	4.2	3,263	$211
42		Pacific Coast Premium Goose Feather & Down Pillow	5.9	Feather & down	No	4.0	780	$34.99
43		EIUE Hotel Collection Pillow	5.8	Down alternative fiber	No	4.3	42,375	$9.99
44		Casper Original Pillow	5.7	Down alternative fiber	No	4.3	12,155	$67.50
45		Puredown Fluffy Goose Feather Down Pillow	5.7	Feather & down	No	4.2	341	$19
46		MyPillow Premium Pillow	5.6	Shredded memory foam	No	4.2	14,044	$39.98
47		Coop Sleep Goods Essence Down Alternative Pillow	5.5	Down alternative fiber	Yes	4.0	1,124	$34.50
48		Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Symphony Pillow	5.4	TEMPUR memory foam	No	4.2	4,919	$74.50
49		MyPillow Classic Pillow	5.2	Shredded memory foam	No	4.0	22,589	$27.49
50		Casper Hybrid Pillow	5.0	Solid memory foam	No	4.2	432	$114.30
51		Purple TwinCloud Pillow	4.9	Down alternative fiber	Yes	4.1	389	$83
52		Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Neck Pillow	4.7	TEMPUR memory foam	No	4.0	8,049	$74.50
53		Purple Cloud Pillow	4.7	Down alternative fiber	No	4.1	1,011	$75

Early reads

Pillows with fewer than 300 ratings

These have a score and a full review, but their rating pools are too small to rank against the list above.

#	Photo	Model	Score	Fill	Adjustable	Stars	Ratings	Per pillow
Early		Pacific Coast Adjustable Cooling Down Pillow	7.8	Feather & down	Yes	4.2	82	$75
Early		Beckham Hotel Collection Adjustable Bed Pillow	7.4	Down alternative fiber	Yes	4.3	133	$39.99
Early		Bedsure PureWoven Hotel Pillow	7.3	Down alternative fiber	No	4.3	122	$25
Early		QUTOOL Crescent Side Sleeper Pillow	7.2	Shredded memory foam	Yes	4.3	232	$32.99
Early		Three Geese Goose Feather & Down Pillow	7.1	Feather & down	No	4.3	239	$27.20
Early		Purple Freeform Pillow	7.0	Gel grid	Yes	4.3	297	$194
Early		Three Geese Goose Feather Pillow, Organic Cotton	7.0	Feather & down	No	4.3	120	$24.99
Early		Beckham Hotel Collection Adjustable Cooling Pillow	6.8	Down alternative fiber	Yes	4.4	199	$69.99
Early		Casper Essential Quilted Select Pillow	6.8	Down alternative fiber	No	4.4	82	$50
Early		Three Geese Cooling Goose Down Feather Pillow	6.5	Feather & down	No	4.2	31	$28.12
Early		Tempur-Pedic TEMPUR-Cloud + Cooling Pillow	6.4	TEMPUR memory foam	No	4.2	166	$79.50
Early		Purple GridCloud Pillow	6.4	Gel grid	No	4.1	136	$149
Early		Serta Cooling Bed Pillow	6.4	Down alternative fiber	No	4.0	116	$30
Early		Three Geese Thin Flat Goose Feather Pillow	6.4	Feather & down	No	4.0	40	$37.49
Early		Utopia Bedding Pintuck Pillow	6.3	Down alternative fiber	No	4.3	50	$10.25
Early		Serta Hotel Collection Pillow	6.2	Feather & down	No	4.0	250	$30.92
Early		Utopia Bedding Memory Foam Pillow	6.2	Solid memory foam	No	4.1	76	$17.09
Early		Puredown Gusseted Hotel Feather Pillow	6.0	Feather & down	No	4.3	274	$14.25
Early		Purple DreamLayer Pillow	5.9	Gel grid	Yes	4.0	272	$194
Early		Pacific Coast White Goose Down Fiber Pillow	5.9	Feather & down	No	4.2	200	$107.50
Early		Pacific Coast Touch of Down Pillow	5.6	Feather & down	No	4.0	89	$84.50
Early		Serta Goose Feather & Down Fiber Pillow	5.5	Feather & down	No	4.0	168	$26.28
Early		Beckham Hotel Collection Down Pillow	5.5	Feather & down	No	4.2	142	$100
Early		Pacific Coast 650 Fill Power Down Pillow	5.2	Feather & down	No	4.0	52	$109.99
Early		Serta Won't Go Flat Pillow	5.1	Down alternative fiber	No	4.0	238	$22.80